Immunotherapy combination yields high response rate compared to earlier single-agent trials
HOUSTON – A tumor-specific vaccine combined with an immune checkpoint inhibitorshrank tumors in one third of patients with incurable cancer related to the human papilloma virus (HPV) in a phase II clinical trial led by investigators at The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center and reported in JAMA Oncology.
“That encouraging response rate is about twice the rate produced by PD1 checkpoint inhibitors in previous clinical trials, so these results will lead to larger, randomized clinical trials of this combination,” said principal investigator Bonnie Glisson, M.D., professor of Thoracic/Head and Neck Medical Oncology and Abell-Hanger Foundation Distinguished Professor at MD Anderson.
Vaccines specific to HPV antigens found on tumors had previously sparked a strong immune response, but had not, by themselves, been active against established cancers, Glisson said.
“Vaccines are revving up the immune system, but the immunosuppressive tumor microenvironment probably prevents them from working,” Glisson said. “Our thinking was that inhibition of PD-1 would address one mechanism of immunosuppression, empowering the vaccine-activated T lymphocytes to attack the cancer.”
The team combined the vaccine ISA101, which targets important peptides produced by the strongly cancer-promoting HPV16 genotype of the virus, along with nivolumab, a checkpoint inhibitor that blocks activation of PD-1 on T cells.
- Eight (33 percent) had a tumor response, two were complete. All eight had oropharyngeal cancer. Median duration of response was 10.3 months.
- Overall median survival was 17.5 months, progression-free survival was 2.7 months and 70 percent of patients survived to 12 months.
- Five of the eight responders remain in response.
“The median survival of 17.5 months for these patients is promising and provides further support for randomized trials testing the contribution of ISA101 to PD-1 inhibition,” Glisson said.
HPV causes nearly all cervical cancers, and most oropharyngeal, anal, penile, vulvarand vaginal cancers. HPV16 and HPV18 are the leading viral genotypes that increase cancer risk. Given the viral cause of these cancers, immunotherapy has been considered a strong potential approach. The researchers note that three previous clinical trials of PD1 inhibitors alone for recurrent HPV-related cancers yielded response rates ranging from 16 to 22 percent.
Two patients had grade 3 or 4 side effects – elevated enzyme levels – that required them to discontinue nivolumab. Glisson said the team observed side effects expected from the two treatments separately, but the researchers were encouraged to see no sign of synergistic side effects caused by the combination.
“That’s important as we develop rational combination immunotherapy,” Glisson said. This clinical trial was among the first to combine vaccination with PD1 inhibition.
Randomized clinical trials of the vaccine and anti-PD1 combination for cervical and oropharyngeal cancer are being organized.
The single-arm trial was an investigator-initiated effort originated at MD Anderson, Glisson noted.
This study was supported by MD Anderson’s Moon Shots Program™, a collaborative effort to accelerate the development of scientific discoveries into clinical advances that save patients’ lives, and MD Anderson’s Cancer Center Support Grant from the National Cancer Institute (P30 CA016672). Philanthropic support also was provided by Mr. and Mrs. Charles W. Stiefel and the Abell-Hanger Foundation Distinguished Professorship.
Bristol-Myers Squibb provided nivolumab and ISA Pharmaceuticals provided the ISA101 vaccine.
Co-authors with Glisson are Erminia Massarelli, M.D., of City of Hope National Medical Center, Duarte, Calif.; William, M.D., Faye Johnson, M.D., Ph.D., Merrill Kies, M.D., Renata Ferrarotto, M.D., and Hai Tran, PharmD., of MD Anderson Thoracic/Head and Neck Medical Oncology; Ming Guo, M.D., of Pathology; Lei Feng and J. Jack Lee, Ph.D., of Biostatistics; Young Uk Kim, Ph.D., and Chantale Bernatchez, Ph.D., of Melanoma Medical Oncology; Cara Haymaker, Ph.D., Tomas Zecchini Barrese, M.D., Jaime Rodriguez Canales, M.D., and Ignacio Wistuba, M.D., of Translational Molecular Pathology; Michael Curran, Ph.D., of Immunology; Lerong Li and Jing Wang, Ph.D., of Bioinformatics and Computational Biology; and Sjoerd H. van der Burg, Ph.D., and Cornelis Melief, Ph.D., of Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, the Netherlands. Melief is also employed by ISA Pharmaceuticals.